By
Pauline Dubkin
Yearwood
Filmmaker Jacky Comforty put
nearly 20 years of his life and several centuries of his
family's history into his documentary "The Optimists."
The film, subtitled "The Story of the Rescue of the
Bulgarian Jews from the Holocaust," is having its world-
premiere theatrical release at the Wilmette Theater.
"The Optimists" has already won a number of awards at film
festivals, including the Peace Prize at the Berlin
International Film Festival. It was directed by Comforty and
written and produced by Comforty and his wife, Lisa. The
couple lives in Evanston.
The full-length documentary tells two interwoven stories,
one of Comforty's own grandfather, Rachamim Comforty, and one
of his fellow Jews of Bulgaria. It's one of the lesser-known
and more inspirational stories of the Holocaust: how all
50,000 Jews were able to survive despite the intensive efforts
of the Bulgarian government to deport them to death camps.
Some of the men spent time in labor camps, but most were
protected and saved by their Christian and Muslim neighbors
and eventually made their way to Israel.
On a deeper level, the film is an examination of the nature
of good and evil and why some people go out of their way to
help their neighbors even when doing so puts them at risk.
Israeli-born Jacky Comforty had been working in TV and
film, making comedies, short subjects and documentaries, for
more than 20 years when the idea for "The Optimists" was born.
It came from his father, who, after his retirement, began
acting in some of his son's films.
"One day he said, 'There is one story you really should
tell-the story of how we were rescued during the war,'"
Comforty related during a recent interview. It was a story
that was new to him. Like many Holocaust survivors, his
parents had told their children little about their wartime
experiences. But on that day in 1984, "I took a little tape
recorder and he and my mom began telling their stories,"
Comforty says.
He immediately decided to make a film based on their
recollections, but knew he needed more information. So he
spent the next four years "reading everything I could get my
hands on about the Holocaust in Bulgaria." During that time,
his father died.
Comforty was in Israel, going through his father's and
grandmother's things, when he came upon a treasure stashed
away in an apartment that had belonged to his grandmother:
shoeboxes filled with photographs from her early life in
Bulgaria, some 1,500 of them.
"There were beautiful postcards and photos," Comforty says,
"including postcards from all my grandmother's admirers who
wrote her from the front during World War I. A lot of museums
wanted us to donate the collection to them." But he knew that
he could use the photos in the film that was now becoming more
of a reality to him.
"Once we had the photos, we were aware that we had a huge
treasure here, and the journey began," Comforty says. That
journey took him to Bulgaria, where- speaking his first
language, Bulgarian- he interviewed more than 100 citizens and
researched the history of the country's Jews not just during
the Holocaust but much farther back.
What he found was a unique community that traced its roots
to an ancient tribe of Jews called Romaniots who spoke a Greek
dialect and came to the country during King Solomon's time.
Even centuries later, Bulgarian Jews considered themselves
Sephardic. They spoke Ladino, an ancient Jewish-Spanish
language, and had an advanced and highly sophisticated
culture. In the 14th century there was even a Jewish queen of
Bulgaria, Comforty relates.
The history transfixed him. "It's truly a fairy tale," he
says. "It's a story I could work the rest of my life-an
unknown story."
Comforty was still learning Bulgarian history when the
demise of communism provided him with another windfall. "The
doors of archives that had been closed for 50 years swung
widely open," he says. "I was very lucky to be there at that
time." He ended up with 5,000 more photographs relating to the
Bulgarian Jewish experience. He also spent months going
through film archives viewing "everything that was done on
film in Bulgaria from the beginning of motion pictures that
had to do with Jewish subjects."
Although he was still working on other films to make a
living and to finance his research in Bulgaria, that
undertaking became his obsession.
"Growing up in Israel, you go to archaeological sites, you
look on the ground and hope to find maybe a coin, but you
never do," he says. "In Bulgaria, everywhere I found
treasures. I went to a synagogue that was closed for 50 years
and found manuscripts, ancient books with layers of dust on
them. It was like in a fairy tale.
"Once you get into the mood of a collector, you cannot
stop," he says. "I was trying to satisfy a hunger that would
not calm down."
Over the next 12 years, Comforty and his wife, whom he
calls "Bulgarian by marriage," worked slowly on the film while
making 40 unrelated documentaries to finance their work. (Even
so, he says, "I was barely paying my bills. I felt like I was
digging a tunnel out of jail.") Originally Comforty planned to
make a four-part series. "There were so many things I wanted
to tell," he says. "The rescue of the Jews during the war was
the result of all the history that went before it. I needed to
explore it all."
He suggests that one of the reasons Bulgarians refused to
hand their Jewish neighbors over to the government can be
found in the centuries of peaceful coexistence between Jews,
Christians and Muslims in Bulgaria and the fact that they
faced a common enemy, the Turks, who oppressed the country for
nearly 500 years.
Finally, he decided that such a big project was
unmanageable and settled for making one film, with hopes to do
the series eventually.
Even filming "The Optimists" was a huge job. "It really was
like archaeology- taking something apart in tiny little shreds
and trying to put it all together and make a very small
piece," Comforty says. "It was overwhelming." The film took
four years to edit and had 6,000 cuts-Comforty says 500 to 800
is the average.
The final version has received awards and praise at a
number of film festivals, but Comforty says he can't take all
the credit for that.
"When you make a film, there is a certain group dynamic
that is beyond your control," he says. "It's not just me or my
skill or my art, but the personalities in the film, the people
who were rescuers, the people whose hearts were in the right
place."
Those people included a teacher who allowed four Jewish
girls-including Comforty's mother-to become kindergarten
teachers even though Jews were officially not allowed into the
classroom. Another story details the efforts of a baker, who,
ironically, hid Jews in his oven.
The title was chosen to work on several levels, Comforty
says. The Optimists was the name of a jazz band that was
highly successful in Bulgaria before the war. One of the
heroes of the film is the sax player, who tells of how a
friend saved him at the last minute, just before he was about
to be put on a train and deported. Later, he recalls putting
on an opera in a labor camp.
The title also has a symbolic level, Comforty says. It
refers to the rescue of the entire community. "The film is
dedicated to those who are optimists," he says.
Of course, that would include the Comfortys. Jacky Comforty
gives a special nod to his wife, who, he says, "suffered
quietly through this for many many years," writing "hundreds"
of grants and making suggestions at every stage.
Now that the film has been released theatrically, Jacky
Comforty's role in it is not finished, he says. He plans to be
present at many of the screenings at the Wilmette Theater and
to organize events around the film, bring in school groups,
answer audience members' questions and engage in dialogues
with viewers.
He stresses that "The Optimists" is not directed solely to
Jews. "It's a film that's meant for all audiences, for all
people," he says. "It's a unique story of individuals who
resisted the government successfully. We don't have many
people who do that."
"The Optimists" is playing at the Wilmette Theater, 1122
Central Ave., Wilmette. Screenings are at 2, 4, 6 and 8 p.m.
daily. For directions call (847) 251-2474. For more
information, visit www.theoptimists.com. Return to
top.